British Litvinenko Death Inquest Descends into Farce

Author: us-russia
Comments: 0
British Litvinenko Death Inquest Descends into Farce
Published 18-03-2013, 14:37

William Dunkerley

William Dunkerley is a media business analyst and consultant based in New Britain, CT. He works extensively with media organizations in Russia and other post-communist countries, and has advised government leaders on strategies for building press freedom and a healthy media sector. He is a Senior Fellow at the American University in Moscow.
The main question arising from last Thursday's hearing in the British Litvinenko death case is whether anyone is actually in charge of the proceedings. Media reports quickly focused on the announced postponement of the May 1 final inquest. Now it's been put off until October.

But the reasons for the delay tell the bigger story: Coroner Sir Robert Owen seems to have lost control of the proceedings, if he ever really had it. The inquest's own legal counsel recited a litany of examples:
  • -- The British government ignored for 10 long months the coroner's request for relevant documents.
  • -- A request for telephone evidence from the Metropolitan Police has not yet been completed.
  • -- Scientific evidence from the police won't be available until the end of April.
  • -- Statements from known witnesses won't be available until the end of April or later.
Keep in mind that we're talking about a death that occurred in 2006. Not ready yet? Who's going to believe that story?

What's more, although the hearing was called to hear applications from parties wishing to give testimony anonymously, none were heard. They weren't ready.

Perhaps as a reflection of his impotence in the case, Owen lashed out with an order of press censorship. He threatens contempt of court charges against journalists and media organizations that publish anything that so much as tends to identify anonymous witnesses. Tends to identify? In whose view? Owen's, I guess. It is completely subjective, and puts Owen in a clear position to intimidate the British press.

The most recent hearing wasn't the first time that Owen's lack of control has been apparent. At the February 27th hearing, he lost control to parties associated with Boris Berezovsky. About half of that hearing was controlled by those people as they advanced the ridiculous accusation that Russia and Britain were conspiring to withhold information vital to the case. If Owen had any control, he should have shut down that nonsense right away.

The Berezovsky clan offered no substantiation for their claims. Their contention turned out to be pure fabrication, just like Berezovsky's initial allegation that President Vladimir Putin ordered Litvinenko's poisoning. Frankly, I don't know whether Putin did or didn't. But Berezovsky and his companions have certainly offered no factual basis for their claims. And they have a long record of inventing false stories to put Putin in a bad light.

If British governmental departments can ignore Owen with impunity, perhaps Prime Minister David Cameron should personally take charge. Presumably he'd be able to enforce compliance. But I don't think even that would bring this case to a believable conclusion. The record has become confounded by lies and fabricated stories. They've apparently permeated the official case. There is little chance of ever finding the truth. The honest course would be to admit that the truth is unattainable, and just dismiss the case and avoid further national embarrassment.
Comments: 0
Experts' Panel
Cuban Missile Crisis Redux. Where...
For those of us with an historical turn of mind, the rapidly...
Cuban Missile Crisis Redux. Where...
Top
popular in the journal
Санкции против России тщетны

Санкции против России тщетны

Вполне возможно, что крымский кризис – тяжелейший из тех, что ударяли по Европе в этом столетии. В данном случае санкции против России повсеместно воспринимаются, ...
The ‘Great Game’ in Europe

The ‘Great Game’ in Europe

In its eagerness to complete the encirclement of Russia by turning Ukraine into a forward country for positioning NATO bases, the U.S. is paving the way for fraternal ...
Ukraine and the grand chessboard

Ukraine and the grand chessboard

The US State Department, via spokeswoman Jennifer Psaki, said that reports of CIA Director John Brennan telling regime changers in Kiev to "conduct tactical operations" ...
Ukraine: Triumph, Tragedy, or...

Ukraine: Triumph, Tragedy, or...

1. In his "The 18th Brumaire of Louis Napoleon” Karl Marx commented dryly on the well-worn truth that history repeats itself: "Hegel remarks somewhere that all great ...
Preparing the Way for the New G-8

Preparing the Way for the New G-8

Washington word games tell it all: the new designation of the G-8 as a format for the ‘world’s biggest industrial economies’ instead of ‘democracies’ prepares the ...